Skip to main content

(DAY 552) Train Travel in India - A Mixed Bag of Progress and Stagnation

· 6 min read
Gaurav Parashar

As India continues to grow and develop, the railway system faces the challenge of keeping pace with increasing demands for efficiency, comfort, and modernization. In recent years, there have been notable efforts to upgrade various aspects of the railway experience, from station renovations to the introduction of new train models. However, the overall improvement in train travel has been somewhat uneven, with certain areas seeing significant progress while others remain largely unchanged.

One of the most visible signs of progress in the Indian Railways has been the renovation and upgrading of railway stations across the country. A prime example of this is the Gandhi Nagar Jaipur Railway Station or Gurgaon Station, which are undergoing through remarkable transformation. The stations soon will boast modern amenities, improved passenger facilities, and a more aesthetically pleasing design. This upgrade is part of a larger initiative to modernize key railway stations and transform them into world-class transit hubs.

However, while station upgrades are certainly a step in the right direction, they represent only one aspect of the overall train travel experience. When it comes to the journey itself, many passengers have noted that there has been little significant improvement in comfort levels over the past five years, particularly in popular classes such as Chair Car and Executive Chair Car.

One of the most common complaints among regular train travelers is the shrinking space within train compartments. As the railways attempt to accommodate more passengers and increase revenue, there has been a tendency to squeeze in additional seats, often at the expense of legroom and overall comfort. This is particularly noticeable in Chair Car and Executive Chair Car classes, which are popular among business travelers and those undertaking day journeys.

The reduction in seat pitch (the distance between seats) has led to a more cramped traveling experience, especially on longer journeys. Passengers often find themselves struggling for space to stretch their legs or work comfortably on their laptops. This issue is compounded during peak travel seasons when trains are often fully booked, leading to overcrowded compartments and a general sense of discomfort among travelers.

Moreover, while some trains have seen upgrades in terms of interior design and amenities, many continue to operate with outdated fittings and facilities. Issues such as malfunctioning air conditioning, poorly maintained toilets, and inadequate food quality on long-distance trains remain persistent problems that detract from the overall travel experience.

Another significant challenge that continues to plague train travel in India is the issue of last-mile connectivity. While the railways have made strides in improving long-distance connectivity between major cities, the journey often doesn't end at the railway station. Many passengers face difficulties in reaching their final destinations from the station, particularly in smaller towns and cities where public transportation options may be limited or unreliable.

The lack of efficient last-mile connectivity options can add significant time and stress to a journey. Passengers often find themselves negotiating with local taxi or auto-rickshaw drivers, who may charge inflated rates, especially to those unfamiliar with the area. While some cities have introduced app-based ride-hailing services that operate from railway stations, this solution is not universally available across the country.

The issue of last-mile connectivity highlights the need for a more integrated approach to transportation planning. Ideally, railway stations should serve as multimodal hubs, seamlessly connecting train services with local buses, metro systems (where available), and other forms of public transport. While some progress has been made in this direction in major metropolitan areas, there is still a long way to go before this becomes the norm across India's vast railway network.

Despite these challenges, there is a bright spot on the horizon for Indian Railways in the form of the Vande Bharat Express trains. These indigenously designed and manufactured semi-high-speed trains represent a significant leap forward in terms of technology, comfort, and passenger experience. The Vande Bharat Express, also known as Train 18, has been hailed as a game-changer for Indian Railways and a symbol of the country's engineering prowess.

The Vande Bharat trains offer several improvements over traditional train services. They boast faster acceleration and deceleration, allowing for reduced journey times between major cities. The interiors are modern and well-designed, with comfortable seating, large windows for better views, and onboard entertainment systems. The trains also feature improved suspension systems for a smoother ride, automatic doors, and bio-vacuum toilets that are more hygienic and environmentally friendly.

Perhaps most importantly, the Vande Bharat Express trains address many of the comfort issues that plague other train classes. The seats are ergonomically designed and offer ample legroom, even in the Chair Car class. The Executive Chair Car in Vande Bharat trains is particularly spacious, providing a level of comfort that rivals business class air travel on some routes.

The introduction of Vande Bharat trains on key routes has been well-received by passengers, with many praising the improved travel experience. However, it's worth noting that these trains currently operate on a limited number of routes, and tickets can be hard to come by due to high demand. The challenge for Indian Railways will be to expand the Vande Bharat network while maintaining the high standards set by the initial services.

The success of the Vande Bharat Express underscores the potential for significant improvements in train travel when there is a concerted effort to innovate and modernize. It serves as a template for what could be achieved across the broader railway network, given sufficient investment and political will. The upgradation of railway stations and the introduction of Vande Bharat trains are positive steps that demonstrate the potential for improvement. However, these advancements need to be balanced against the ongoing issues of passenger comfort in regular train services and the lack of efficient last-mile connectivity. Additionally, there needs to be a greater focus on maintaining and upgrading existing rolling stock. While the introduction of new, advanced trains like the Vande Bharat Express is commendable, the vast majority of passengers still travel on older trains. Improving the condition and comfort levels of these trains should be a priority to ensure a more equitable improvement in the overall train travel experience.

While the Indian Railways has made strides in certain areas over the past five years, the overall experience of train travel for the average passenger has not seen dramatic improvements. The success of initiatives like station upgrades and the Vande Bharat Express shows what can be achieved with focused efforts and investment. However, these improvements need to be extended more broadly across the railway network to benefit a larger section of travelers. The Vande Bharat trains represent a significant step forward and should indeed be welcomed as the future of Indian Railways. Their success should serve as an impetus for further modernization efforts across the entire rail network. As India continues to grow and develop, a modern, efficient, and comfortable railway system will be crucial in supporting the country's economic and social progress. The challenge now is to build on the successes, address the persistent issues, and work towards a railway system that truly meets the needs and expectations of 21st-century India.